Rubric

Keep in mind that 34 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Facilitation
Facilitation
Criteria Ratings Pts
Reading Notes (Student)
Reading Notes (3 points): Each student in the facilitation group will prepare Reading Notes for ALL of the required readings that day. Write 2-3 singled-spaced pages of notes for each reading. Use bullet-point format. The instructor will post the Reading Notes the night before class for everyone to read.
threshold: pts
3 pts Full Marks
0 pts No Marks
pts
3 pts
--
Annotations (Student)
Annotations (2 points): Each student in the facilitation group will be responsible for making critical annotations (notes/comments) on ALL of the required readings you’re doing for your Facilitation. Students will work individually on their annotations but be able to see other students’ annotations and reply to them. We are using the Hypothesis tool in Canvas to annotate a pdf file. Please do all of the following to complete the Annotations component:
Write annotations on ALL of the readings assigned to your group for that day.
Write a total of at least FOUR (4) comments/notes in which you respond to a particular claim or sentence or small section of the text you’ve been assigned to annotate. Keep your annotations brief so that everyone else can read them in a short amount of time. Just write a short sentence or two and/or a question.
Write at least FOUR (4) brief replies or questions to the annotations that peer(s) have made.
threshold: pts
2 pts Full Marks
0 pts No Marks
pts
2 pts
--
Engagement (Student)
Engagement (2 points): Each student in the facilitation group must be prepared to engage with classmates’ answers to the discussion questions and ideas that get expressed in class about all of the required readings for that day. You will do this synchronously during class, in the whole class discussion and in breakout groups. Be ready to pose follow-up questions and comments, as the discussion develops that day. If any student will be asynchronous for this component, they must notify their group and the instructor in advance, and complete the “engagement” requirements in writing, which will be given in the Class Activity for that day.
threshold: pts
2 pts Full Marks
0 pts No Marks
pts
2 pts
--
Peer Evaluation (Student)
Submit your completed form here (completing this will count towards your overall Participation grade).
threshold: pts
0 pts Full Marks
0 pts No Marks
pts
0 pts
--
Methods & Themes (Group)
Historical Methods & Key Themes - do both A & B (3 points):
A. Your group will identify & briefly analyze some of the historical methods used by the authors of the readings. Consider two or more of these prompts (these are condensed from Richards and Burch, “Documents, Ethics, and the Disability Historian):
-How disability historians find or select their sources (archives, oral histories, official vs. vernacular documents, etc.).
-What approaches they take in interpreting them.
-What goals and concerns they state for disseminating their research (accountability, privacy, accessibility, etc).
B. Your group will compile a list and define a total of about 5 key themes or new concepts that were raised in the readings that day.
threshold: pts
3 pts Full Marks
0 pts No Marks
pts
3 pts
--
Presentation (Group)
Presentation (2.5 points): At the start of the class period, members of the facilitation group are responsible for presenting a general overview of each of the required readings. Prepare a short introduction to who the authors are, and brief summaries of the thesis, main points, key concepts, and key examples and evidence you identified in the texts.
For accessibility, please create a PowerPoint for your presentation. The PPT file should be no more than about 8 slides total, and it must be submitted by 5pm the day before you present. The instructor will do the screen share in Zoom.
threshold: pts
2.5 pts Full Marks
0 pts No Marks
pts
2.5 pts
--
Questions & Plan (Group)
Discussion questions and class activity plan (3 points): Prepare at total of six (6) discussion questions for the class activity that day, and make a plan for what order they should be discussed in and which questions will be used in breakout sessions and which in whole-class discussion. These should be open-ended questions that will generate substantial class discussion. At least two of your questions should attempt to draw out connecting themes between texts. The instructor will post the questions and the class activity plan in the day’s discussion board so that all students can access them.
threshold: pts
2.5 pts Full Marks
0 pts No Marks
pts
2.5 pts
--