Rubric

Find Rubric
Keep in mind that 37 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
process book
process book
Criteria Ratings Pts
decision origins
threshold: pts
2 pts
clearly identifies not only major design decisions, but their origins
1 pts
identifies most major design decisions and their origins, but some origins are vague or unstated.
0 pts
the book describes some major decisions, but does little to describe their origins.
pts
2 pts
--
polish
threshold: pts
2 pts
the document was largely devoid of Illegible diagrams, clutter, misspellings, grammar issues, and image resolution problems.
1 pts
the document had some of these issues, distracting from the content
0 pts
the document had many of these issues, making it difficult to focus on the content
pts
2 pts
--
storytelling
threshold: pts
2 pts
the book tells a compelling, engaging story, and encourages the reader to finish reading.
1 pts
the book is engaging in some ways, but feels like a list of events at other times.
0 pts
the book reads like a list of events and does little to keep the reader interested.
pts
2 pts
--
reflection
threshold: pts
2 pts
the book contains reflection on the quality of the process in concrete and insightful ways.
1 pts
the book reflects on the quality of the process, but in vague and non-specific ways.
0 pts
the book does not reflect on the quality of the process.
pts
2 pts
--
conciseness
threshold: pts
2 pts
the book is efficient with its words, choosing only those necessary to convey the points.
1 pts
some of the book's writing could have been more concise while still conveying the same points.
0 pts
the book is unnecessarily verbose, detracting from the storytelling.
pts
2 pts
--
individual contributions
threshold: pts
2 pts
the book clearly explains the author's role in the design process.
1 pts
the book explains the author's role in most of the design process, but at times it is left unstated or is unclear.
0 pts
the book provides little detail about the author's role in the process.
pts
2 pts
--
Total Points: 12 out of 12