Formative Assessment

Overview

As you work on the assessments and activities appropriate for your course, it is useful to consider the role of formative and summative assessment. One way to define these that might make sense to you:

  • Formative assessment is assessment as learning
  • Summative assessment is assessment of learning

These two modes of assessment are not in competition, but together provide a solid approach to assessment supporting student learning as a holistic process.

In their book Checking for Understanding Links to an external site., Douglas Fisher and Nancy Frey provide a useful table outlining key differences between formative and summative assessment:

Formative and Summative assessment characteristics

Formative assessment often involves students considering or answering metacognitive questions such as:

  • What did I learn?
  • What questions do I still have?
  • How can I apply what I learned?

Examples

The Yale Poorvu Center for Teaching and Learning shares some general examples Links to an external site. contrasting the two kinds of assessment:

Formative Summative
In-class discussions Instructor-created exams
Clicker questions Standardized tests
Low-stakes group work Final projects
Weekly quizzes Final essays
1-minute reflection writing assignments Final presentations
Homework assignments Final reports
Surveys Final Grades

Implementation

Many of the assessment methods discussed next can be used to implement formative or summative assessment, though simpler assessments and those that can be set up to provide automatic feedback (such as Quizzes) will be most suited to formative assessment.