Rubric

Find Rubric
Keep in mind that 27 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Paper (Part 2) Rubric
Paper (Part 2) Rubric
Criteria Ratings Pts
Argument
threshold: pts
50 pts
Argument is convincing, original, and focused on the essay prompt; the argument is clearly stated and masterfully maintained throughout the piece.
43 pts
Argument is original and focused on the essay prompt, but it could be more original, clearer, and/or convincing. The argument is maintained throughout the piece.
37 pts
Argument is present and focused on the essay prompt, but it lacks originality and could be clearer. The argument is roughly maintained throughout the piece.
27 pts
Argument is weak but focused on the essay prompt; argument lacks originality and has significant problems. The argument drops out in parts of the piece.
0 pts
No argument is present, or the argument raised makes no sense and has substantial problems. The argument is not present throughout the majority of the piece.
pts
50 pts
--
Evidence
threshold: pts
80 pts
Argument is masterfully supported with specific evidence drawn from assigned readings; valuable insights and connections to the texts and course themes have been made; relevant dates & names (ID terms) have been used in key places.
70 pts
Argument is strongly supported with evidence drawn from assigned readings; standard connections to the texts and course themes have been made; relevant dates & names (ID terms) have been used.
58 pts
Argument is supported with evidence drawn from assigned readings, but evidence could be better used or more specific; some connections to the texts & course themes have been made, but these are superficial; relevant dates & names (ID terms) have been used in some places.
42 pts
Attempts are made to support the argument with evidence from assigned readings, but evidence is poorly used; almost no connections to the texts and course themes have been made; many relevant dates & names (ID terms) are missing.
0 pts
Evidence is missing or substantially flawed; no connections to the texts and course themes have been made; little to no attempt is made to include relevant dates & names (ID terms).
pts
80 pts
--
Paper Structure
threshold: pts
35 pts
Essay is a well-organized paper with an introduction, body, and conclusion; paper is organized around coherent paragraphs with transitions & effective topic sentences clearly tied to the argument & analysis.
31 pts
Essay is an organized paper with an introduction, body, and conclusion; paper is organized around paragraphs, but transitions & topic sentences could be stronger and/or more clearly tied to argument & analysis.
22 pts
Essay is organized with an introduction, body, and conclusion; paper is organized into paragraphs, but transitions & topic sentences are somewhat weak and not always clearly tied to the argument & analysis.
13 pts
Organization of essay is flawed, without a clear introduction, body, and conclusion; paragraphs are poorly organized & lack transitions; topic sentences are sometimes missing and/or poorly connected to the argument.
0 pts
Essay lacks organization; paragraphs appear to be haphazard with problematic topic sentences & transitions, if present at all.
pts
35 pts
--
Polish
threshold: pts
30 pts
Essay is nearly free of stylistic and grammatical errors and has been edited and refined.
26 pts
Essay is largely free of stylistic and grammatical errors and has been edited.
21 pts
Essay contains some stylistic and grammatical errors, but they do not interfere with understanding the paper; more time should have been spent editing.
13 pts
Essay contains numerous stylistic and grammatical errors that make the paper confusing at times; far more time should have been spent editing.
0 pts
Essay is riddled with stylistic and grammatical errors that make the entire paper difficult to read; little to no editing has been done.
pts
30 pts
--
Citation
threshold: pts
30 pts
Footnote citations follow the Chicago Manual of Style format and are nearly free of errors.
25 pts
Footnote citations follow the Chicago Manual of Style format and are largely free of errors.
15 pts
Footnote citations follow the Chicago Manual of Style format, but have some errors.
10 pts
Some attempt at using footnote (or endnote) citations is made, but they fail to adhere to the Chicago Manual of Style format and/or have substantial errors.
0 pts
No footnote (or endnote) citations are used; if they are present, they are inaccurate, largely incomplete, and/or riddled with numerous errors.
pts
30 pts
--
Improvement
threshold: pts
25 pts
Essay reflects substantial improvement over previous writing assignments.
21 pts
Essay reflects adequate improvement over previous writing assignments.
13 pts
Essay reflects modest improvement over previous writing assignments.
8 pts
Essay reflects little improvement over previous writing assignments.
0 pts
Essay reflects no improvement over previous writing assignments.
pts
25 pts
--
Total Points: 250 out of 250