• The proposal's problem description is well-researched and persuasive
• The proposal's design description is clear in its concept and rationale
• The proposal's tradeoff analysis humbly and insightfully identifies the limitations of who the design exclude or harm
• The proposal's problem description is superficial but factual
• The proposal's design description is complete, but occasionally vague
• The proposal's tradeoff analysis superficially examines who the design would exclude or harm
• The proposal's problem description is logically flawed
• The proposal's design description is incomplete and often unjustified
• The proposal's tradeoff analysis does not discuss who the design would exclude or harm