Rubric

Find Rubric
Keep in mind that 3 students have already been assessed using this rubric. Changing it will affect their evaluations.
Design (4)
Design (4)
Criteria Ratings Pts
Excellence
threshold: pts
4 pts
Excellent
• The proposal's problem description is well-researched and persuasive • The proposal's design description is clear in its concept and rationale • The proposal's tradeoff analysis humbly and insightfully identifies the limitations of who the design exclude or harm
3 pts
Good
• The proposal's problem description is superficial but factual • The proposal's design description is complete, but occasionally vague • The proposal's tradeoff analysis superficially examines who the design would exclude or harm
2 pts
Okay
• The proposal's problem description is logically flawed • The proposal's design description is incomplete and often unjustified • The proposal's tradeoff analysis does not discuss who the design would exclude or harm
1 pts
Poor
• The proposal's problem description is missing • The proposal's design description is mostly unclear • The proposal's tradeoff analysis is missing
0 pts
Missing
No proposal was submitted, the document did not propose an information system, or credit was not given for the origins of the writing.
pts
4 pts
--
Total Points: 4 out of 4